If it had been up to Erik ten Hag, who has since been dismissed by Manchester United, Scott McTominay would still be playing for the club. The Scottish midfielder casually revealed this in an interview with the BBC. However, McTominay chose to sign for Napoli instead.
Embed from Getty Images
Last summer, Scott McTominay made a high-profile move from Manchester United to Napoli for over thirty million euros, a transfer that surprised many at the time.
For McTominay, the decision to leave his boyhood club was not taken lightly. Having spent nearly two decades at United, where he arrived as a young boy at the age of five, McTominay had grown through the ranks to become a reliable presence in midfield. His departure marked the end of a long chapter with Manchester United and the beginning of a bold new adventure in Italy.
According to McTominay, the transfer was one he fully supported, as did the club's management, who saw the deal as a good financial opportunity for United. However, the Scottish midfielder revealed in a candid interview with the BBC that Erik ten Hag, United's manager at the time, was reluctant to let him go. "I spoke with him [Ten Hag]," McTominay explained. "He gave me his opinion on the situation and what he thought was best for me and for the team. But I had to make a decision that was right for me."
Ten Hag, who valued McTominay's physicality, work rate, and leadership qualities, saw him as a player who could still contribute significantly to United's midfield. Given the challenges United faced last season, Ten Hag's preference to keep McTominay was understandable. The Dutchman had been navigating injuries to key players, inconsistencies in form, and the growing demands of competing in multiple competitions. Losing a dependable midfielder like McTominay was a setback Ten Hag hoped to avoid.
Despite the manager's plea, McTominay ultimately decided to take control of his future. "It was difficult to leave the club I had been at for so long, where I grew up and where I learned so much," McTominay admitted. "But I said to him, 'Listen, it's my career, and I need to push myself forward. I have to follow my feelings and not let external factors hold me back.'" This sentiment underscores the ambition that drove McTominay to make a fresh start in Serie A, despite the comfort and security of his role at United.
For many players, leaving a club of Manchester United's stature comes with significant pressure, but for McTominay, the move to Napoli has been nothing short of a success. The Scottish midfielder has flourished under Antonio Conte, who took over at Napoli with a clear vision and strong tactical approach. Known for demanding intensity, discipline, and work ethic from his players, Conte found an ideal match in McTominay, whose tireless energy and versatility have become essential to Napoli's midfield.
Napoli, the reigning Serie A champions, are once again embroiled in a thrilling title race this season, and McTominay's contributions have been pivotal. In fifteen official matches, he has scored four goals, a notable output for a player whose primary role is often defensive or box-to-box. His ability to make late runs into the box, win aerial duels, and contribute in both attack and defense has earned him the admiration of Napoli fans and the trust of Conte.
Conte's system has allowed McTominay to thrive, giving him more freedom to showcase his attacking instincts while maintaining his tenacity in recovering possession. The Scottish international’s knack for turning up in decisive moments whether with a crucial tackle or a goal has brought an added dimension to Napoli’s midfield. His performances have also silenced critics who doubted whether he could adapt to the technical and tactical demands of Italian football.
The move to Napoli has not only been beneficial for McTominay on the pitch but also off it. The midfielder has embraced the challenge of living in a new country and immersing himself in a different footballing culture. "It’s been a learning experience," McTominay said in a recent interview. "The way football is played here is so tactical, and you have to think about every move. Antonio Conte has pushed me to improve in ways I never imagined."
For Napoli, McTominay represents more than just a strong midfield addition. He embodies the hunger and work ethic that Conte has been building his team around. His quick integration into the squad and consistent performances have made him a fan favorite at the Stadio Diego Armando Maradona.
Meanwhile, Manchester United have had a mixed start to the season, and questions continue to arise over whether McTominay's departure left a gap in their squad. United's midfield has struggled at times, particularly with injuries to players like Casemiro and Christian Eriksen. For Erik ten Hag, the loss of McTominay one of his most physically reliable midfielders may have been felt more deeply than anticipated.
As McTominay continues to make waves in Italy, his move to Napoli serves as a reminder of the rewards that come with taking bold decisions. His success in Serie A highlights his ability to adapt, grow, and thrive under new challenges. For the Scottish midfielder, the decision to leave Manchester United despite the emotional ties and Ten Hag's wishes has proven to be the right one.
Now an integral part of a Napoli side pushing for consecutive Serie A titles, McTominay has firmly established himself as one of the standout midfielders in Italian football this season. His performances have not gone unnoticed, with speculation already building about his future role in both club and international football. Whether helping Napoli secure another Scudetto or leading Scotland in their next major tournament, McTominay's bold step into the unknown has undoubtedly paid off.
In hindsight, while Ten Hag's desire to keep him at Old Trafford was understandable, McTominay's move has shown that sometimes following your instincts leads to the greatest rewards. For now, Napoli fans can celebrate having a player whose ambition and hard work are helping to drive their title charge, while Manchester United fans may look on with a sense of what might have been.
Updated: 04:05, 17 Dec 2024
